My love affair with Van Halen dates back many years. I would like to say I have been a fan since their first album came out in 1978, but I was only 6 years old at the time and my parents’ favorite song was Sonny and Cher’s “I Got You Babe”, so it’s not like they would’ve picked up a copy for themselves.
The first release that I think I was aware of was 1984, which came out when I was in 6th grade. I think I knew who Eddie Van Halen was, but only because he was married to Valerie Bertinelli. Even after 1984 came out, I was only a casual fan. I didn’t care about the back catalog.
That all changed when David Lee Roth quit and, later, when Sammy Hagar was named the lead singer. Van Halen was big news and I knew Sammy Hagar from “I Can’t Drive 55” and I was officially hooked. I became obsessed and I’m pretty sure I bought 5150 on the day it was released. It was in 9th grade when I finally got around to completing my Van Halen catalog. In 9th grade, there was a new kid that started at our school and we sat together in Biology class. I think he heard me mention Diver Down and he said that he had that album. We bonded over Van Halen and are still great friends today.
Van Halen means a lot to me. I love all types of music, but there’s something different for me about hearing Van Halen music. I can feel my mood change and a wave of joy washes over me. I’m not sure what it is about the music that affects me that way. While I enjoy the David Lee Roth era better, I get the same feeling for Sammy Hagar era Van Halen, too. I’ll have to listen to Van Halen 3 again to see if Gary Cherone gives me the same feeling, but probably not. (Sorry Gary, however, I am a HUGE Extreme fan.)
In the early to mid-nineties, I was part of a Van Halen internet mailing list that Valerie Bertinelli lurked, and occasionally chimed in, on. I remember one day, Valerie Bertinelli posted this (or something very similar) to the mailing list: “You guys are not going to believe what’s going on here.” Shortly after, news broke of DLR’s return. When David Lee Roth recorded the two tracks for the Greatest Hits album in 1996, I was thrilled. I think the two songs, “Me Wise Magic” and “Can’t Get This Stuff No More” are awesome and I don’t know why most fans aren’t that crazy about them. While I was sad that Sammy Hagar was gone, getting DLR back was a major coup and I couldn’t wait for a new album and tour, since I had never seen Van Halen with David Lee Roth.
But, as we know, David Lee Roth got screwed over (or there was just a pretty severe misunderstanding) and Gary Cherone came in as the new lead singer. I wanted to see them in concert with Gary because I knew they were playing a lot of old stuff (i.e., deep cuts) live. I had seen VH with Sammy about 4 times and, to be honest, I got kind of bored with seeing them because they always played the same DLR-era songs and they didn’t really mix up the set list much with Sammy-era songs (i.e., stuck to the hits).
When David Lee Roth got back together with the band in 2007, I was a bit skeptical. I didn’t think it would last. I did buy tickets to see them, but the date was changed 2 times due to Eddie’s health and I just ended up selling the tickets. Also, while I was bummed that Michael Anthony wasn’t asked back, I was encouraged that, because of his age, Wolfgang would be able to infuse a new energy into the band. Based on the song selection for the tour — reportedly picked by Wolfgang — I was right. After the tour ended in 2008, not much Van Halen news came out. They kind of disappeared off the map.
Honestly, I don’t really care to see Van Halen live. I’ve listened to all of those songs a million times and the thrill of seeing them played in front of me is not as appealing to me as it once was. I just desperately wanted new music. I craved it. When Sammy Hagar and Michael Anthony formed Chickenfoot, I thought it was closest thing to new Van Halen music that I was ever going to get. It was good and I liked it and it provided a similar mood altering effect on me, but it wasn’t Van Halen.
In 2011, news reports started circulating of Van Halen recording a new album with David Lee Roth. I wasn’t sure what to make of it. I didn’t know whether to be wary or excited. I chose to remain a bit guarded, so that I wouldn’t be disappointed if it didn’t pan out. The album was completed last fall, but there was no release date in sight. Then, they signed to Interscope and I was ready for the marketing onslaught. (What are the chances of David Lee Roth being a mentor on American Idol this year? I think pretty high and I wonder if that’s one of the reasons they signed to Interscope.)
I heard reports that a lot of the material was based on demos they did prior to their first album. That really got me interested because I have a lot of those demos and there are some really amazing songs on there that have never seen the light of day.
In January, they finally released the first single, “Tattoo”. Did I like the song? Yes. Was it what I was expecting? Not even close.
Tattoo wasn’t very heavy and had kind of a pop feel to it. I literally (and I do mean “literally” in the truest sense) listened to the song over 100 times that week. I didn’t really ever get sick of the song, so that was a good sign. None of my friends (and I mean none of my friends liked it). While I enjoyed the song, if the rest of the album sounded like this, I would be disappointed. I wanted tunes that hit you over the head with Eddie’s guitar and had the typical David Lee Roth swagger.
In the weeks leading up to the release of the new album (A Different Kind of Truth — great album title), Van Halen started releasing 90 second previews of each song. With the sample of China Town, I finally heard what I was hoping for. Following China Town, almost all of the new songs previewed had a hard and heavy feel. Some riffs I recognized immediately from the old demos. For other riffs, I had to read through the comments on the Van Halen News Desk for someone to fill me in.
When I first heard about them using old demos as the basis for these songs, I was worried that Eddie lost his creativity and ability to write new songs. However, there are plenty of songs on A Different Kind of Truth that are brand new (to me, at least) that are fantastic.
I am not going to give a track-by-track review of the album, although I will say that I think Tattoo is the outlier and probably should’ve been left off the album. Everything else is stellar. There are two songs that I didn’t like when I heard the previews, but enjoy much more now that I have heard the whole album: “Blood and Fire” and “Stay Frosty”.
Rather than do a track-by-track review, I will list the songs that are based on old demos and provide links to versions of the originals on YouTube. You can also listen to previews of the new songs on iTunes.
New Song | Original Version |
---|---|
Tattoo | Down In Flames |
She’s The Woman | She’s The Woman |
You and Your Blues | N/A |
China Town | N/A |
Blood and Fire | Ripley Instrumental from the movie The Wild Life |
Bullethead | Bullethead |
As Is | Two Burritos and a Root Beer Float from Eddie’s appearance on Two and a Half Men |
Honeybabysweetiedoll | N/A |
The Trouble With Never | N/A |
Outta Space | Let’s Get Rockin’ |
Stay Frosty | N/A |
Big River | Big Trouble |
Beats Workin’ | Put Out The Lights |
I’m kind of hoping that they release a box set or something, so that clean versions of the old demos are released. As good as the songs on the new album are, a couple of the original songs are better than the new incarnations.
Because they have new matieral to play in concert, I did decide to go see them live and I’m looking forward to it. Especially because Eddie seems healthier than he’s been in years (or even decades?). I’m looking forward to an amazing show. Since they are playing in Atlantic City on a Saturday night, my wife and I are going to make a weekend out of it. Maybe I’ll run into David Lee Roth roaming around the Borgata.
Truly, I am just ecstatic that Van Halen is back in full force. It’d be great if they could put out a new album every year like they did from Van Halen I through 1984, but I don’t think that’s possible anymore. I just hope that A Different Kind of Truth is just the beginning and not their swan song. Stay Frosty.